Kukla's Korner Hockey

Kukla's Korner Hockey

NHL GMs Agree To Keep Regular Season OT Format

03/18/2024 at 5:47pm EDT

from Nicholas J. Cotsonika of the NHL's website,

Each time NHL general managers gather for their annual three-day meeting in March, they receive a report on statistical trends.

The most interesting nugget Monday?

The NHL is on track to have 70 percent of extra-time games end in overtime this season, which would be a record.

That's important, because some GMs have expressed concern about 3-on-3 OT -- too much regrouping, not enough attacking.

A small group of GMs discussed it at a breakout session Monday and will report to the full group of GMs on Tuesday.

In the end, the feeling is that the League should leave it alone. Changes could lead to unintended consequences and be self-defeating, and the format is doing what it was designed to do: reduce shootouts.

"I think it's working," said New York Islanders general manager Lou Lamoriello, whose team has played 18 OT games, tied with the Boston Bruins for the most in the NHL. "I don't think there's any need to make changes. I think if the regroups were causing it to go into a shootout, then you'd have to."

continued

Paul

from Dan Rosen of NHL.com,

The process for video review and the potential to expand the coach's challenge rule are again topics of discussion at the annual March meetings of the NHL general managers that began Monday and runs through Wednesday.

It was among the topics talked about in small group breakout sessions Monday and will be brought to the entire group of general managers and League executives here Tuesday for further discussion.

"We talk about that every meeting," said Colin Campbell, the NHL's senior executive vice president of hockey operations. "I talked to the NFL at one point at the outdoor games in Jersey and their challenge is like ours and all sports, where do we go in trying to make our game perfect with video review and how long does it take to make those reviews?"

Campbell said the discussion Monday included a conversation about allowing coaches to challenge plays involving pucks shot over the glass from the defensive zone that should or should not result in a delay of game penalty.

continued

TreKronor

I think I can get behind just keeping the OT format the way it is.  We've seen the evolution of how overtime is played, and it's been interesting to watch these last few years since 3 vs. 3 was introduced.  The first few years, most of the goals were scored on the second possession's breakout, within 45 seconds of OT starting.  Now, there's more gamesmanship going into it and calculated decisions being made.  I like that.  

Adding possession rules with a cross-over line is a good way to make the game unnecessarily complex where you are just going back to having breakout after breakout.  

What I HAVE NOT liked with the OT format is the one game against the Wings where the other team (Ottawa, maybe?) possessed the puck for like two and a half minutes and just waited until they got the best possible looks to shoot.  That was annoying, and I fear that's going to be a trend in the future.  Without putting a sort of shot-clock in place, that's tough to prevent simply because there is so much open ice to defend with three guys.  I hope that style doesn't become more used, and hopefully it was just an anomaly because the Wings were doing so poorly at defending that night.

Sven22

If the goal is to reduce shootouts why not make 3-on-3 OT longer?

If 70 percent of games end within 5 minutes of 3-on-3, that suggests that about 91 percent would conclude inside of 10 minutes, 97 percent inside 15, and 99.2 percent inside 20.

Personally I'd love 20 minute 3-on-3, and if nobody scores it's a tie. No more shootouts and in the whole league you might have 0-5 ties per year. 

Sven22

Also: get rid of the offside challenge.

Offsides exists to prevent teams from either cherry picking or using the whole ice keep possession and slow the game down. Linesmen do their best to call it accurately but it's unreasonable to expect perfection when guys are skating in at 20 mph across a 85-foot-wide line at the same time as a 3-inch puck. 

I feel like if a linesman is doing his job correctly, anything that looks like a tie or too close to call, don't blow the whistle. Give the benefit of the doubt to the attacking team and let the players play. 

If it's that close anyway, than the spirit of the rule has been upheld. No one is getting a critical advantage from being an inch offside. 

Create an Account

In order to leave a comment, please create an account.

About Kukla's Korner Hockey

Paul Kukla founded Kukla’s Korner in 2005 and the site has since become the must-read site on the ‘net for all the latest happenings around the NHL.

From breaking news to in-depth stories around the league, KK Hockey is updated with fresh stories all day long and will bring you the latest news as quickly as possible.

Email Paul anytime at [email protected]

Most Recent Posts

Most Recent Comments

Comment by dca in Abel to Yzerman from the entry Paying David Perron - 27 minutes ago
Comment by dca in Kukla's Korner Hockey from the entry The NHL Draft Lottery Will Be Held On May 7th - 29 minutes ago
Comment by dca in Kukla's Korner Hockey from the entry The NHL Draft Lottery Will Be Held On May 7th - 31 minutes ago
Comment by OffSeid in Abel to Yzerman from the entry Do The Wings Need Another Goalie? - 49 minutes ago
Comment by OffSeid in Abel to Yzerman from the entry Playoff Hockey Starts Tonight For The Grand Rapids Griffins - 1 hour ago