Kukla's Korner

Canucks and Beyond

Rating the Canucks Without Malhotra

The injury to Manny Malhotra is first and foremost a terrible event for he and his family, and we all certainly hope for a quick and complete recovery for his sake.  But from a hockey standpoint, it presents a very serious challenge to the Canucks as well. 

For one thing, it’s fair to say that stats in the faceoff circle are a concern.  Though maybe help could come from an unexpected source?  Gordon McIntyre at The Province finds a willing ego to step up to tackle the problem:

“We’re deep on defence,” Bieksa said. “I don’t know how deep we are at centre. I just beat half the forwards out there on faceoffs after practice.”

Shudder.  (But he’s kidding. You hope.) But then again, who is going to fill Malhotra’s skates?

No doubt, the team has high hopes for Chris Higgins, but he’s a career-winger not a center, and as McIntyre notes in the article above, Alain Vigneault very conspicuously avoided praising Higgins’ faceoff skills yesterday. We can probably assume Chris isn’t the new magic man of the faceoff circle. 

But really, the loss of Malhotra is a far bigger loss than just the faceoff circle, despite the current talking points. 

Malhotra and his line are arguably the best third line in hockey (I said “arguably”, please note; don’t freak out). When they’re on the ice, Malhotra, Raffi Torres, Jannik Hansen are one very tough line to play against, shutting down some of the best in the game on a regular basis.  For a team like Vancouver, where “just a 1-line team” and (on good days) “just a 2-line team” have been the knocks on them for years, a third line this good is a monster asset they’ve not often enjoyed. From Malhotra’s faceoff skills, to the line’s overall chemistry, that’s going to be near-impossible to replace.

Higgins will get his chance. Maybe someone else in Manitoba?  But whomever ends up in there, it’s going to be a very different line.  And my bet: not nearly as effective as it’s been to this point.

One fan said to me today that the loss of Malhotra—and the potential shakeup it creates—is enough for him to go from believing the Canucks might be favorites in these playoffs, to being just another “very, very good”  team. 

His point wasn’t to imply that Malhotra was more important than the stars of the team… only that this Canucks team is a well-oiled machine.  What happens when one of the parts falls off a well-oiled machine?

They’re still going to win a lot of games, and they may even adapt to this setback without much of an interruption… but on their road to win a Stanley Cup, I’m guessing the Canucks themselves aren’t taking this lightly. 

From Kevin Bieksa on a more serious note yesterday:

“You could even call him our most valuable player for the season.  With all the things he does, he’s a leader in the dressing room and off the ice, and on the ice with faceoffs and penalty kill, and he’s a voice on the bench. He does a lot things, but I think first and foremost we hope he’s okay heath-wise and he has a full recovery.”



Filed in: vancouver canucks, | Canucks and Beyond | Permalink
  Tags: jannik+hansen, manny+malhotra, raffi+torres


Alanah McGinley's avatar

Raymond is worth a shot, and I’ve always liked him, but as you point out, he plays a different game than Malhotra.  It’ll be interesting to see how effective that line is with a different style in there.

Posted by Alanah McGinley from British Columbia on 03/18/11 at 06:08 PM ET

Luongo-is-my-hero's avatar

nothing will replace maholtra,  he means a lot more to the team then what he puts on the scoreboard. hopefully we get him back during the playoffs, but im not going to be holding my breath.  In all honesty it puts a serious damper into our chances of winning the cup.

Posted by Luongo-is-my-hero on 03/19/11 at 12:13 AM ET

Add a Comment

Please limit embedded image or media size to 575 pixels wide.

Add your own avatar by joining Kukla's Korner, or logging in and uploading one in your member control panel.

Captchas bug you? Join KK or log in and you won't have to bother.

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.

Most Recent Blog Posts

About Canucks and Beyond

Alanah McGinley has been blogging hockey since 2003 (with a notable gap in time through 2010, kicking it with new baby Lucy while living knee-deep in chaos while reading "parenting for complete idiots" during every spare minute) sharing opinions, rants and not-so-deep thoughts with anyone who will listen.

In addition to writing Canucks & Beyond and helping manage Kukla's Korner, Alanah was one of the founders and co-hosts of The Crazy Canucks Podcast. She has contributed pieces to FoxSports.com and the New York Times Slapshot blog, as well as other stray destinations in cyberspace.

So that's me. Who the hell are you? smile

Email: am@kuklaskorner.com

Alanah's Twitter: [@alanah1]