by PuckStopsHere on 05/06/14 at 10:29 PM ET
Over the last couple of weeks the finalists for the NHL awards (at least those that interest me) have been announced. While I have already posted who I would vote for if I had an award ballot, we can infer a lot more from looking at the award nominees. Here are my comments on the finalists that have been announced:
Calder Trophy: Tyler Johnson Tampa Bay Lightning, Nathan MacKinnon Colorado Avalanche, Ondrej Palat Tampa Bay Lightning. These are the three highest scoring rookies. I wouldn't be surprised if they finish in the order of their point totals meaning MacKinnon gets the award. Missing out is Torey Krug of Boston. He is the top scoring defenceman this year and did a very good job as the power play point man for the top team in the regular season. The argument against Krug was that he didn't play as many minutes as top defencemen - though he played more minutes than any of the Calder nominee forwards. Given the minutes Zdeno Chara plays that is probably an unreasonable expectation for Krug. I have him as a close second behind MacKinnon.
Selke Trophy: Patrice Bergeron Boston Bruins, Anze Kopitar Los Angeles Kings, Jonathan Toews Chicago Blackhawks. These were the same three players I would have supported. I think Bergeron will win.
Adams Trophy: Mike Babcock Detroit Red Wings, Jon Cooper Tampa Bay Lightning, Patrick Roy Colorado Avalanche. I think this shows a poor idea of who to vote for as coach of the year. I expect Patrick Roy wins the award. Colorado took a big step forward in points. Part of it was his ability to make Colorado a fun place to play. Part of it was being in the right place at the right time. It wasn't Roy's technical ability as a coach because that is a weakness of his. Nevertheless I put him in third place on my ballot. Jon Cooper is not an above average NHL coach. The emergence of goalie Ben Bishop made him look good. Similarly, Roy benefitted from the emergence of Semyon Varlamov. The easiest way to be an overrated coach is to have a top goalie emerge around the time you are hired. In terms of his technical ability, Mike Babcock is by far the best coach nominated this year. He won't win. On a historical basis, there is no reason to support him this year in particular when he hasn't been a top coach of the year nominee in the recent past. Detroit jumped to the easier conference and nevertheless fell in the standings with injuries to key players. That doesn't mean Babcock is not a good coach, but it doesn't make him coach of the most improved team. I had Bruce Boudreau and Ken Hitchcock as my top two choices. They are proven good coaches who were behind teams that did very well this year. I see them as better candidates this year than any of the coaches actually nominated.
Masterton Trophy: Jaromir Jagr New Jersey Devils, Manny Malhotra Carolina Hurricanes, Dominic Moore New York Rangers. I hope Malhotra wins. The fact he is in the NHL at all after a serious eye injury that hampered him for years and having to work his way back through the AHL is the kind of story that should win this award. I think Dominic Moore may win. Being in a larger media market will help his case. He overcame the emotional issue of losing his wife, but there was no physical issue associated with it as Malhotra had. I think Jaromir Jagr will be a distant third. He is basically nominated for having a long career.
Lady Byng Trophy: Patrick Marleau San Jose Sharks, Ryan O'Reilly Colorado Avalanche, Martin St Louis New York Rangers. I think O'Reilly wins because of his absurdly low two penalty minutes this season even though he isn't as good a player as either other finalist. An issue was raised over the St Louis nomination by those who argued that his asking for a trade from Tampa Bay was not gentlemanly. I would argue that is not the intent of the award. It is intended to award on ice play and our modern era of increased access to players has allowed us to see aspects of players that we never used to see. That was never intended to be included in the criteria for this award. St Louis is definitely a talented and gentlemanly hockey player. I think Tyler Seguin deserved a nomination in place of Patrick Marleau. He was roughly equal in terms of gentlemanly play and had a better seasn than any of the nominees.
Norris Trophy: Zdeno Chara Boston Bruins, Duncan Keith Chicago Blackhawks, Shea Weber Nashville Predators. I think Keith should win handily. I think that there were a wide range of candidates worthy of some mention behind him. I think Chara is beginning to show his age and is not as good as he once was. I didn't have him in my top six. I think he gets the benefit of the doubt because his team finished first overall. I had Alex Pietrangelo and Ryan Suter as my other nominees. I think it is interesting that they were the top three players by ice time in the playoffs first round along with Keith. that shows their value to their respective teams - though it can't be taken as a knock against Shea Weber since Nashville missed the playoffs. Pietrangelo and Suter have not built their reputation as top defencemen on the level that Chara and Weber have and were overlooked more for reputation than their play on the ice.
Vezina Trophy: Ben Bishop Tampa Bay Lightning, Tuukka Rask Boston Bruins, Semyon Varlamov Colorado Avalanche. I think Bishop secured his nomination in the general managers' minds by February and despite the fact his play suffered beyond that point, they never had second thoughts. Carey Price is a far better nominee who had a better season. Tuukka Rask should win he has the best reputation of any of these goalies and had the best season.
Hart Trophy: Sidney Crosby Pittsburgh Penguins, Ryan Getzlaf Anaheim Ducks, Claude Giroux Philadelphia Flyers. These are the top three scorers in the NHL. Sidney Crosby should win easily. He could be a unamimous choice. I had Duncan Keith as my second pick. He was the best defenceman in the NHL by a significant margin. Giroux shouldn't be nominated. He had a good offensive season in the weaker conference where scoring was easier. He doesn't have any above average defensive ability or puck possession numbers. The point totals will likely mirror their finish in the voting.
Add a Comment
Please limit embedded image or media size to 575 pixels wide.
Most Recent Blog Posts
About The Puck Stops Here
Who am I? A diehard hockey fan.
Why am I blogging? I want to.
Why are you reading it? ???