by PuckStopsHere on 02/09/14 at 03:41 PM ET
Last summer, Steve Simmons made an ill-advised comment about Corsi in his weekly column. He wrote:
Another reason why I have next to great difficulty for the CORSI analytic statistic in hockey. I saw a team adjusted CORSI ranking for this past season. Tyler Seguin of the Bruins was rated fifth best in the NHL. The same Seguin whom Bruins coach Claude Julien kept on the third line, moving rookie Carl Soderberg from press box to first-line centre when Patrice Bergeron got hurt. I’ll take Julien’s instincts over strange numbers anytime
This prompted me to write a response. As predicted in that response, time has made Simmons comment look even stupider. His comment suggests that something is wrong with Corsi ranking because a player he doesn't agree with does well. This would be equivalent to somebody arguing that goals cannot be a meaningful statistic because Joe Pavelski is currently fifth in the NHL in goals and there is no possible way that Pavelski is the fifth best player in the NHL. It is a strawman argument that comes from not understanding what goals or Corsi measures.
What makes Simmons look even sillier is that Tyler Seguin would be the line in the sand that he draws. Seguin is a young talented player who was clearly ready to break out. His puck possession numbers showed it. Watching him play would show it. Steve Simmons couldn't see it.
Tyler Seguin is currently the 13th highest scorer in the NHL. He is leading his Dallas team in points. He is showing himself to be a star player in the NHL. He would have made most Olympic teams this year. Because he is a Canadian and Canada is very deep and he doesn't have the long track record of some players, he didn't make the Canadian team in 2014, but it looks like he would be a prime candidate for Canadian Olympic Teams for years into the future.
If you want to look stupid, you can make a strawman argument against a statistic you do not understand. If you are going to do that, at least do not pick a young player who is about to make a significant breakthrough as your line in the sand. Tyler Seguin is an NHL star. His star is quickly rising. Picking a rising star as the player you think doesn't belong at the top of a group of Corsi ranking leaders will make you look really silly as that player becomes a star. Tyler Seguin is doing that and he is making Steve Simmons look silly. However, given the soundbite method to Simmons columns, I don't expect that this criticism will be ever addressed by him. It will be ignored with the hope that most people don't remember or notice how silly that comment was.
Add a Comment
Please limit embedded image or media size to 575 pixels wide.
Most Recent Blog Posts
About The Puck Stops Here
Who am I? A diehard hockey fan.
Why am I blogging? I want to.
Why are you reading it? ???