Over a week ago, the Stephane Auger/ Alexandre Burrows incident came to light. It is alleged that referee Stephane Auger warned Burrows before a game that a Burrows dive in a previous game had made him look bad and then proceeded to make a couple marginal to poor calls against Burrows in the game of that day to “even things up“. The NHL responded by fining Burrows for speaking to the media about the incident and then closed the books. More official NHL media have moved on and are trying to help the incident be forgotten. It is up to independent members of the blogosphere to keep the story alive.
Tom Benjamin wrote a good piece on how this issue should be framed. The issue is not about putting Burrows character on trial. The issue is not about how to punish diving. Those may be separate issues worth thinking about, but the issue that is brought to light is that referees (at least one) make a conscious decision to not be impartial in games. They plan to “go after” a certain player or players because of a personal vendetta and do not care if that changes the outcome of the game. This calls into jeopardy the idea that the game is officiated impartially.
In September, I wrote that the Tampa Bay Lightning might be the next NHL team in bankruptcy. It seems that they are headed down that path. The team is in default on the loan that they took out with the former owner for their initial purchase, according to Bruce McLeod of the Macomb Daily (a Michigan newspaper).
The current Tampa Bay ownership group was never on strong footing. Oren Koules, producer of the Saw Movies and Len Barrie, a former NHL player who had real estate in Victoria, BC (and some minority partners) purchased the team in 2008 under the name OK Hockey LLC. They promptly made some short-sighted but attention grabbing player moves and public announcements which made them very newsworthy figures for a few months. The moves did not work out and Tampa Bay was quickly reduced from recent former Stanley Cup champion to a team that is struggling at the gate,
Every season since I started to blog, I picked out one team that could improve the most if they added a top level goaltender. Since a goaltending is the player that has the biggest impact on a team`s success, it is quite likely that this team will have a big jump in success if they do find that goalie. This happened in 2005/06 when Edmonton added Dwayne Roloson at the trade deadline and went to the Stanley Cup finals. Last year, my pick was the Detroit Red Wings. They were a very good team last year that struggled much of the season in goal due to a poor regular season from Chris Osgood. They were a team one top goalie short of being an elite team. Detroit never added that goalie and nevertheless went to the finals and lost. Osgood played much better in his playoff run than he did in the regular season.
Ironically, this year`s Detroit team seems to have found their goalie in Jim Howard, but the team in front of him is not nearly as good due to a combination of player losses, injury and age related decline.
Over the past couple of years, Jeff Schultz has been a whipping boy among Washington Capitals fans. He has been the team`s number six or seven defenceman and a relatively frequent healthy scratch. He has been given a lot of criticism for his apparent lack of effort. This season, as Schultz has the second highest +/- rating in the league (+27 - one point back of teammate Alexander Ovechkin), he is showing that he can be an above average NHL defenceman.
Schultz is a former first round draft pick. He was selected 27th overall by Washington in 2004. He is one of the larger defencemen in the game at 6‘6“ and 230 pounds. Historically these large defencemen tend to take a few years to fully develop into NHL players. As a comparison, reigning Norris Trophy winner Zdeno Chara (6‘9“ and 255 pounds) had an 11 point -27 +/- season in 65 games with the New York Islanders when he was Schultz`s age (23).
This summer when the Calgary Flames added Jay Bouwmeester, they were a popular choice to be the top defence in the NHL. Bouwmeester was joining Robyn Regehr and Dion Phaneuf. They were to form the best top three on any defence unit in the NHL. If former Vezina Trophy winning goaltender Miikka Kiprusoff bounced back into form behind that defence, this was a Flames team that could dominate. They could allow the least goals against in the NHL and be a Stanley Cup contender.
There was a solid chance that Calgary would provide three of the Canadian Olympic Team defencemen. When the team was actually named, Calgary had zero defencemen on the roster. What happened?
The CHL Top Prospects Game is this Wednesday in Windsor, Ontario. It pits two teams of the top players who are draft eligible in 2010 who play on teams in the three CHL leagues. The teams are coached by Don Cherry and Bobby Orr and are thus called Team Cherry and Team Orr.
Here are the rosters for the CHL Top Prospects Game:
Of the major NHL awards, I think the Masterton Trophy is the one that has the most ambiguous description of who wins it. It is officially given to the player who best exemplifies the qualities of perseverence, sportsmanship and dedication to hockey. In practise, I think the award goes to the player who overcomes the biggest adversity anevertheless contributes the most to his team. That is how I pick it and it is consistent history. Despite the fact it is explicitly mentioned in the award description, sportsmanship plays little or no impact in the selection of Masterton winners.
I think the man who best fits this description this season is Patrice Bergeron of the Boston Bruins. Bergeron essentially lost his 2007/08 season to a concussion. He only managed to play ten games. Although he was back last season, he was not the same player he had been in the past. This year he has been the top scorer on the Boston Bruins and is on the roster for the Canadian Olympic Team.
The Toronto Maple Leafs have the worst penalty kill in the NHL this season. They have killed 68.9% of opposing team’s penalties. The second worst team is the Edmonton Oilers who are over 7% better with a 76% success rate. The NHL has recorded penalty kill success rates since the 1963/64 season and this year’s Leafs team has the third worst rate in history. Behind the Net Hockey has a nice summary of the worst penalty kills in history.
The two teams that were worse in raw percentage than this year’s Maple Leafs are the 1979/80 Los Angeles Kings and the 1982/83 Kings who came in at 67.7% and 68.24% respectively. With a bad game or two, the Leafs could be in that range. In fact at times they have fallen behind the 83 Kings penalty kill rate only to recover a bit.
In December I picked Mike Green of the Washington Capitals as the top defenceman in the season so far. At that point, the race for Norris Trophy was most likely between Green, Duncan Keith of Chicago and Drew Doughty of Los Angeles. Since that time, Doughty has fallen off the pace and Keith has come on strong. He is closing the gap in points and +/- with Green. Currently Keith has 42 points to Green’s 46 and has a +16 to Green’s +17. The main difference between them comes in the fact that Duncan Keith plays against the some of the toughest opposition that Chicago faces and Green plays against a more average level of competition. It is in the tougher competition he faces that Duncan Keith that he makes himself the Norris Trophy leader at this point.
Duncan Keith is clearly having the best season of his NHL career to date. In 46 games played he has 42 points. His previous best (established last season) was 44 points and that took 77 games and that was a strong enough season defensively to earn Keith a sixth place finish in the Norris Trophy voting. Keith has maintained his defensive strength and added an offensive component to his game that makes him the second best offensive defenceman in the world (behind Mike Green). Keith has established himself as the best defenceman in the league so far this season.
In order for the NHL to be a credible sports league, the impression must exist that teams decide who wins the games on the ice. There cannot be an impression that officials (either on or off ice) can decide these things. Reality is that decisions by officials often impact NHL games. As long as any influence is random and cancels out in the longterm, it is an acceptable situation for the NHL, but this is not an acceptable position for the NHL public. Many members of the public must believe that teams are the only factor in deciding who wins games in order for the league to maintain credibility.
That is why the allegations that referee Stephane Auger was out to get Alexandre Burrows of the Vancouver Canucks in Monday night’s game versus Nashville (which Nashville won 3-2) are serious. It opens the door to fans who had previously believed that the players decide games to the idea that officials play a much bigger role in the outcomes.
About The Puck Stops Here
Who am I? A diehard hockey fan.
Why am I blogging? I want to.
Why are you reading it? ???