Kukla's Korner

The Puck Stops Here

Top 20 Adjusted +/- Ratings (Rate Stat)

A few days ago, I listed the top 20 adjusted +/- ratings calculated as a counting stat.  I went on to write about Jeff Schultz of the Washington Capitals leading the league and the interpretation of that fact.  I was asked the intelligent question by a commenter called GoPens about why these results show some discrepancies with what he had seen using +/- as a rate stat.  The rate stat adjustment looks at +/- calculated per minute of play, while the counting stat adjustment looks at the total numbers accomplished in the entire season.  Both are useful.  The rate stat adjustment is better at finding seldom used players who are doing quite well and the counting stat adjustment is better at finding the top performances in the league.  It is essentially the difference between goals scored and goals per game.  I would argue that the counting stat is often more useful, in the same way that it is more useful to have a fifty goal scorer on your team than a guy who scored at a 50 goal pace but only played 10 games.

I think it is useful to look at the top adjusted +/- ratings when calculated as a rate stat and compare with the counting stat list.  So here is the rate stat list (this is calculated from behind the net and only includes players with at least 50 games played in the 2009/10 regular season):

2009/10 Top 20 Adjusted +/- Ratings (Rate Stat)
Adj +/- 
Rank in Counting Top 20 
1Mark FistricDal+2.64


2Daniel SedinVan+2.54


3Alexander OvechkinWas+2.08


4Steve DownieTB+2.03


5Henrik SedinVan+1.95


6Dustin PennerEdm+1.90


7Jeff SchultzWas+1.81


8Zach PariseNJ+1.80


9Cody FransenNas+1.74


10Travis ZajacNJ+1.69


11Ladislav SmidEdm+1.66


12Marian GaborikNYR+1.66


13Wojtech WolskiPhx+1.47


14Matt CookePit+1.39


15Patric HornqvistNas+1.39


16Christian EhrhoffVan+1.37


17Nik AntropovAtl+1.37


18Mike GreenWas+1.36


19Benoit PouliotMon+1.36


20Scott ParseLA+1.34


The top players appear on both lists but with their order shuffled.  The bottom half of these lists tend to deviate from one another more than they do at the top.  The rate stat list will tend to have more players who did not play very much and thus did not accumulate big enough counting numbers.  As a result it is harder for a defenceman to make this list.  There are six defencemen in the top 20 rate adjusted +/- list (Fistric, Schultz, Smid, Franson, Ehrhoff and Green) and nine on the counting list (Schultz, Fistric, Ehrhoff, Green, Rafalski, Pronger, Lidstrom, Chara and Carle).  Some significant all star defencemen made the counting list and not the rate list.  The only defencemen on the rate list but not the counting list are Ladislav Smid of the Oilers who was limited to 51 games played this season and Cody Fransen of the Predators who was limited to 61 games.

As for the exact order of the players on this list, Mark Fistric is a bit of a surprising number one.  He did very well on the counting list (number three) as well.  I promised a future post about Mark Fistric on the counting list post and it is even more clear that it is needed after seeing him leading this list.  That will come soon.

Plus minus can be adjusted to attempt to remove team effects in multiple ways.  The most common two methods treat it as a counting stat and as a rate stat respectively.  Both are looking for slightly different things and it is expected that they should produce different (but similar) results.  They are useful methods to find players who performed well in their roles in a given season.  The rate stat adjustment, shown today, is better able to locate players who had good underlying numbers but limited playing time, while the counting stat adjustment is better able to find players who had strong seasons.

Filed in: | The Puck Stops Here | Permalink


Be the first to comment.

Add a Comment

Please limit embedded image or media size to 575 pixels wide.

Add your own avatar by joining Kukla's Korner, or logging in and uploading one in your member control panel.

Captchas bug you? Join KK or log in and you won't have to bother.


Notify me of follow-up comments?


Most Recent Blog Posts

About The Puck Stops Here

imageThe Puck Stops Here was founded during the 2004/05 lockout as a place to rant about hockey. The original site contains over 1000 posts, some of which were also published on FoxSports.com.

Who am I? A diehard hockey fan.

Why am I blogging? I want to.

Why are you reading it? ???

Email: y2kfhl@hotmail.com