Kukla's Korner

The Puck Stops Here

Future Hall Of Famer Sergei Fedorov Retires

I like to keep track of the players in hockey who i think should make the Hall of Fame regardless of what they do in the rest of their careers.  When these players retire I like to write a career retrospective.  Today I am writing about Sergei Fedorov who announced this weekend that he would retire to become the GM of CSKA Moscow in the KHL.

Fedorov was born on December 13th, 1969 in Pskov, USSR, which is in the western part of the former Soviet Union.  He first became known to hockey scouts when he debuted in the Soviet Elite League at the age of 16 and 17 with Dynamo Minsk, in what is today Belarus.  A young Fedorov scored six goals and seven points in only fifteen games played.

Fedorov was selected for service in the Central Red Army as he was clearly a talented young player.  This service would be fulfilled by playing hockey for CSKA Moscow.  There he quickly became one of the top prospects in Russian hockey.  He was setup with linemates Alexander Mogilny and Pavel Bure as the heir apparent to the KLM (Krutov-Larionov-Makarov) forward line who had dominated for the Soviets in international play.  He made the tournament all star team at the 1988 World Junior Hockey Championships where he scored 12 points in 7 games.  By 1989 he was playing for the Soviets internationally in the World Championships.  He was drafted in the fourth round 74th overall by the Detroit Red Wings in the summer of 1989.  He would have been selected much earlier if his eligibility to play in North America was clearer.  At that point it looked like he was stuck behind the iron curtain for the foreseeable future.  That changed in 1990 when Fedorov slipped away from Soviet team at the Goodwill Games in Seattle and boarded a plane to Detroit to defect from the Soviet system.

He made his NHL debut in 1990 scoring 79 points in 77 games in his rookie year.  He made the All Rookie Team that season.  Despite defecting, Fedorov was a key part of the Soviet team in the 1991 Canada Cup.  In his second NHL season his offensive numbers improved, as he posted 86 points and made the NHL All Star Game for the first of six times in his career.  He won the fastest skater competition in the NHL Skills Competition.  This was a victory he repeated in 1994.  By 1994, Fedorov was full-blown superstar.  He scored 120 points and won the Hart Trophy as the NHL MVP along with the Frank J Selke Award as best defensive forward in the league, First Team All Star and Lester Pearson Award as the players choice as MVP.  The 1994/95 lockout shortened season was Fedorov’s first significant playoff run.  Detroit lost in the finals to the New Jersey Devils, but Fedorov led the league in both assists (with 17) and points (with 24) in the playoffs.  He had another strong season in 1995/96 where he posted his second 100 point season (with 107 points) and he led the playoffs in assists (with 18) despite Detroit failing to advance past the semi-finals.  Fedorov won his second Selke Trophy in this season.  In the next year, 1997, Fedorov won the Stanley Cup for the first time with the Detroit Red Wings. 

Fedorov then looked for a big payday.  He held out the majority of the 1997/98 season as a restricted free agent.  Eventually he signed an offer sheet with the Carolina Hurricanes.  Fedorov would potentially make $28 million in the first year of his front-loaded deal.  This deal included a $12 million bonus if his team made the semi-finals.  This was seen as a somewhat unfair contract term as Carolina had little chance of advancing that far and it was quite likely with the defending Stanley Cup champions in Detroit.  Nevertheless the NHL allowed it to stand and Detroit matched the offer, thus retaining his rights.  Fedorov returned in late February and played only 21 regular season games.  He earned his $12 million bonus as Detroit repeated as Stanley Cup champions and Fedorov was the top goal scorer in the playoffs (with 10).  This $28 million payday was the largest sum of money a player has ever made for one season of NHL play.  Along the way, Fedorov played for Russia in the 1998 Olympics and won a silver medal.  In 2002, he won his third Stanley Cup with Detroit and also won the Hardest Shot competition in the All Star Break.  He won a bronze medal playing for Russia in the 2002 Olympics.

In the summer of 2003 he left Detroit and signed as a free agent with the Mighty Ducks of Anaheim.  He stayed there for one complete year plus the 2004/05 lockout season.  He was unable to rise to the levels that he had in Detroit and was traded to Columbus early in the 2005/06 season.

The trade was Fedorov and a 2006 fifth round draft pick to Columbus for Tyler Wright and Francois Beauchemin.  Largely it was seen as a salary dump by Anaheim.  Fedorov spent the better part of three seasons in Columbus but he was not a top scorer there.  He was traded to Washington as part of the 2008 trade deadline.

This trade was for a college defenceman named Ted Ruth who has never played an NHL game.  Fedorov had a bit of a resurgence with Washington as he got to play with better linemates than he had in Columbus.  When his contract expired decided to return to Russia to play with Metallurg Magnitogorsk in the KHL.  He played there for three years and was a KHL All Star.  In 2012 he was captain of one of the all star teams. 

In his NHL career, Fedorov played 1248 games scoring 483 goals 696 assists for 1179 points.  He added 176 more points in 183 playoff games.  These numbers could have been even bigger were it not for time spent playing in the Soviet Union and Russia early and late in his career.

Fedorov lived like a rock star.  He was linked romantically to tennis player Anna Kournikova and Tara Reid.  He has had financial issues due to being defrauded of $60 million in an investment scam.  He has yet to be able to receive any compensation for this.  Fedorov was an extremely talented player who succeeded in Russia, North America and internationally.  He was criticized for not remaining interested in doing his best at hockey in his Anaheim and Columbus years and might have had even better numbers in different circumstances.  Here was the post where I first considered him a Hall of Famer.

With Fedorov’s retirement we are left with fourteen active future Hall of Famers.  Here is the list:

Daniel Alfredsson
Martin Brodeur
Zdeno Chara
Sidney Crosby
Dominik Hasek
Jarome Iginla
Jaromir Jagr
Nicklas Lidstrom
Alexander Ovechkin
Chris Pronger
Martin St Louis
Teemu Selanne
Tim Thomas
Joe Thornton

As hockey continues to be played this season we may see additions to this list.  We will likely see retirements this summer.  Dominik Hasek is the most likely.  He took last season off and claims he is likely to retire for good if a serious offer does not come soon.  Nicklas Lidstrom, Daniel Alfredsson and Teemu Selanne are also players who are considered candidates for retirement this summer.  Chris Pronger is another who might have played his final NHL game and is on the longterm injured reserve in Philadelphia.

Filed in: | The Puck Stops Here | Permalink



Great article.. Although Thorton and Thomas for the HOF is a stretch.

Posted by Malik_is_alive on 05/15/12 at 05:15 PM ET


Joe Thornton led the NHL in points in the 2000-2010 decade. He’s 5th in all-time scoring amongst active players (after Jagr, Selanne, Lidstrom and Alfredsson).

Is he a clear cut, home run of a hall of famer? I don’t think so. Is he worthy? I’d say yes. I think he’ll get in: no one elected in the past two seasons was clearly a better NHL player than him.

Posted by Jean on 05/15/12 at 05:34 PM ET


Tim Thomas? Two Vezina, Stanley and a Connsmythe is very impressive, but I still don’t know about Hall Of Fame. Its still only a 7 yr career, I think he would need another trophy to get in. I don’t believe there is 1 goalie currently in the Hall with less then 2 cups.

Vernon, Barrasso, Vachon, Moog, Hextall, Osgood all still waiting and all in my opinion better resume.

Posted by Roboshow from Calgary on 05/15/12 at 06:04 PM ET


Sorry, Eddy is a 1 time stanley winner

Posted by Roboshow from Calgary on 05/15/12 at 06:06 PM ET

PuckStopsHere's avatar

Evaluating goalies based upon cups won is pretty stupid.  It merely picks goalies on good teams. 

If you need an example of a Hall of Fame goalie with no Stanley Cups look up Eddie Giacomin.

Interesting that you name six goalies who are not in the Hall of Fame and none of those six have won the Vezina twice as Thomas did - the majority on your list never won it at all.

While I do not want to turn these comments into a referendum on Tim Thomas, your arguments against him are badly lacking.  With any scrutiny, your arguments against Tim Thomas show he belongs in the hall.

Posted by PuckStopsHere on 05/15/12 at 06:12 PM ET


Wins 196, playoff wins 29, it would be by far the lowest in the Hall, guys with 300+ are waiting.

Your argument for Vezina could also be flawed, if Stanleys are flawed, Rask has but up equal # when he plays with they steller D.

Not saying he couldn’t be HOF, but I wouldn’t count on it.

Posted by Roboshow from Calgary on 05/15/12 at 06:22 PM ET

w2j2's avatar

Sergei Federov was a fantastic player.  He had tremendous speed & great hands, and was exciting to watch as a fan.  He played tough in the clutch.  Hall of Famer, for sure.

Posted by w2j2 on 05/15/12 at 06:37 PM ET

PuckStopsHere's avatar


You make up facts to support your argument.  I recommend you look up Alex Connell,.Hap Holmes, Georges Vezina etc. when you make blanket statements about wins totals.  Of course you are aware that wins are a team stat and are a poor evaluator for an individual goalie.

Your claim Rask has equal numbers to Thomas is false.  Thomas had the highest saves percentage since the stat has been measured in 2010/11.  When did Rask do that?  When did Rask ever have a Vezina year (or even a year that made him a contender)?  How about the Conn Smythe? 

You are grasping at straws and many of these straws you claim you have are false.

Posted by PuckStopsHere on 05/15/12 at 08:11 PM ET


Interesting that you name six goalies who are not in the Hall of Fame and none of those six have won the Vezina twice as Thomas did - the majority on your list never won it at all.

To reiterate PSH’s point, as far as I know, no goalie who was eligible for a Vezina trophy for any significant portion of time since that trophy has existed and did not win has been inducted to the HHoF. It’s a de facto prerequesite at that position.

There are arguments against Thomas’ induction, but “Osgood and Moog aren’t in” isn’t one of them. Thomas checked all the tough boxes, these two weren’t good enough to get all of them at any point in their careers.

Barrasso might have a beef with a Thomas induction, though. Two championships, a calder, a vezina, 3 runner-ups in the vezina voting, I think, some type of all-time assist record and a crapload more career wins.

Posted by larry from pitt on 05/15/12 at 09:56 PM ET


Not sure what facts I made up PSH, but OK

29 playoff wins would be the only one I need in my simple little mind. 16 in 1 yr(which is gr8) but only 13 other playoff wins in the career, please.

Sorry for turning a Sergei post into a Thomas thing, my bad.

Posted by Roboshow from Calgary on 05/16/12 at 12:17 AM ET

PuckStopsHere's avatar


You claimed Thomas had low win totals for a hall of fame goalie.  I listed a few for you to look up who have lesser totals.  That takes some of the wind out of that claim.

In the end Tim Thomas does not make the Hall of Fame because of the ridiculously high number of playoff wins he has.  That would be a poor method to pick Hall of Famers.  It would reward a long career on a good team but not necessarily a good goalie (see for example Chris Osgood).  Thomas does however make the Hall of fame as a goalie who had significant playoff success.  Conn Smythe Trophy winner last year while setting a saves record.

Posted by PuckStopsHere on 05/16/12 at 12:40 AM ET


My last post, we wont agree, nor do we have to, not saying he won’t get in, just would be surprised with the resume he has today.

Goalies who played 90’s to now, get in-

waiting- Vernon, Barrasso, Moog, Hextall, Osgood, maybe Cujo.

I wouldn’t put Thomas past these guys who have been waiting and will still wait, and will maybe never get in, despite cups, vezinas, conns, large regular season and playoff wins.
Maybe he has a couple playoffs before he is done like Hasek, 10win, 13 win, 10 win, then sure maybe.

Spent way to much time on this, oh man, Later.

Posted by Roboshow from Calgary on 05/16/12 at 01:40 AM ET

Add a Comment

Please limit embedded image or media size to 575 pixels wide.

Add your own avatar by joining Kukla's Korner, or logging in and uploading one in your member control panel.

Captchas bug you? Join KK or log in and you won't have to bother.


Notify me of follow-up comments?


Most Recent Blog Posts

About The Puck Stops Here

imageThe Puck Stops Here was founded during the 2004/05 lockout as a place to rant about hockey. The original site contains over 1000 posts, some of which were also published on FoxSports.com.

Who am I? A diehard hockey fan.

Why am I blogging? I want to.

Why are you reading it? ???

Email: y2kfhl@hotmail.com